The review overall is good and I agree with your overall assessment though I
would've given Mononoke Hime a little bit higher rating.
What you do need to work on (and it seems most everyone has this problem) is
that you have too much in story summary. Instead of laying out the entire story
in a plot synopsis, review it. There was less review in that section then plot
summary. You just gotta work on that. Good work though all in all, keep it up.
If I was to go totally unbiased here I have to say that your rating is a little
slightly higher rating than I would've given it. But because I am a hardcore
RuroKen fan I have to say it deserved a perfect 10. But I hate bein biased
Overall good review, though your overview was everything but brief. Try to lay
off a little on the overview of the storyline and just stick with your opinions
about it. And the review on the storyline felt more like I was reading the
overview instead of a review. That was the only problem with it otherwise good
work and keep writing ^_^x
lol yeah sometimes I feel I given it a better score than it should've gotten but
the Music and Art, as I said was the saving grace of this anime. So in the end
thats what kept it an above average anime.
I don't believe in lacked in moral at all. Every episode had its own moral to it
as a stand alone episode and when you take a step back and look at the series in
general there is one big moral to it all.
I like the review. Simplistic and straight to the point. Very understandable. I
didn't have to read it twice to understand what you were talking about despite
not having seen the series in about 4 months.
Wow nice criticism...maybe...but this manga is deep. Unfortunately I guess, by
your reaction to my review, I was not able to express clearly in words. Maybe
I'll edit it later to try and explain it better for those who don't quite get
what I am refering too.
I have to agree with you for the most part of the initial run of the series and
the end except that the bigger picture of the story was having two mini-stories
in one huge story. They have two sets of main characters (in this case
Shinn/Kira and Shinn/Athrun) and play each set in a different time. The first 15
were about Kira and Shinn and how they were going to fight. Of course Kira made
his decision fairly quickly, but it took Shinn a lot more than a small nudge to
make his decision on how and who he was going to fight. The second half, the
next 15 episodes, were Athrun and Shinn. We get more into why Athrun chose what
he did and continuing on with who Shinn was fighting for. The last 21 episodes
was a merging of both stories into one for a grand finale ending to the series.
Unfortunately in the end, the writers of GSD didn't do a very good job of this.
They weren't able to correctly give spotlight to each main character as equally
as they should.
All in all I enjoyed your detailed review and I agree with most of it. Good
work, keep writing.
I have to agree with you in most areas except for two parts. The first part was
Dark's japanese voice. I actually prefer that over the english voice. It fits
Dark's character more considering he is suppose to be several years older than
Daisuke as far as how they look. He was supposed to be portrayed as a 17 to 18
year old male not a 14 year old that is why his voice was deeper which suited
him best. The second part was your rating for the story. Yes we all have our
opinions on animes. I just felt your rating was a tad lower than the story
should've gotten. Overall great review but lay back on the abbreviations like
'OMG'. It just doesn't work will in a review ^_^
Well I appreciate what you guys said, but my review was not biased. I did this
review from the most neutral stand point. I, as a viewer, just couldn't find
many things wrong with this series. I'm sorry if my unbiased opinion doesn't
meet up to other people's review of this series. I tried to think of things
wrong with this series but in the end, I couldn't think of anything major. The
minor things I found that were wrong with it I clearly stated in my review.
*hint hint* why this review didn't give the show a 10. If I was truly biased I
would've gone that route.
I just want to say in response: "Well excuse me for having such a small
vocabulary. Sorry I am not as perfect as you are and I'm sorry that my OPINION
(which frankly that is what a review is) doesn't match up to your
standards."
You know what, I have to give props, because this is the first review I have
read that I agree with 100%. Every rating you gave are the ratings I would give.
Maybe for slightly different reasons but they are about the same. Great review,
I enjoyed reading it.
I agree with you mostly about this anime. Its very well done and its got the
tone that makes you want to watch it again. Though I can't agree with you when
it comes to both art and presentation. I thought the art was excellent and I
believe (despite having low budget) they made a right choice in making the art
what it is. It set the tone for the anime. Presentation I believe was also well
done, yes some points it gets boring in the serious if you don't quite
understand what is going on but it is very interesting to watch every scene even
if none of the episodes connect til the end. But that is just my opinion.
Overall great review and I appreciate the scroe you gave this series on the
music and story cause it deserves those 10s.
Another good interview, but I didn't care for this anime too much. It got
extremely confusing at points in which it should've been clear. I do agree with
the music though if that is some consolation.
Silver so you know I reviewed the ANIME not the MANGA. If I reviewed the manga it would probably get a 9.5 out of 10. The Manga is definitely better.
The review overall is good and I agree with your overall assessment though I would've given Mononoke Hime a little bit higher rating.
What you do need to work on (and it seems most everyone has this problem) is that you have too much in story summary. Instead of laying out the entire story in a plot synopsis, review it. There was less review in that section then plot summary. You just gotta work on that. Good work though all in all, keep it up.
If I was to go totally unbiased here I have to say that your rating is a little slightly higher rating than I would've given it. But because I am a hardcore RuroKen fan I have to say it deserved a perfect 10. But I hate bein biased
Overall good review, though your overview was everything but brief. Try to lay off a little on the overview of the storyline and just stick with your opinions about it. And the review on the storyline felt more like I was reading the overview instead of a review. That was the only problem with it otherwise good work and keep writing ^_^x
lol yeah sometimes I feel I given it a better score than it should've gotten but the Music and Art, as I said was the saving grace of this anime. So in the end thats what kept it an above average anime.
I don't believe in lacked in moral at all. Every episode had its own moral to it as a stand alone episode and when you take a step back and look at the series in general there is one big moral to it all.
I like the review. Simplistic and straight to the point. Very understandable. I didn't have to read it twice to understand what you were talking about despite not having seen the series in about 4 months.
Yes I did want another character to win, but I won't say who ^_^ you guys will just have to guess.
And yes there is a game coming out called Strawberry Diaries, I believe thats what its called. I don't know too much about it. Google it.
Wow nice criticism...maybe...but this manga is deep. Unfortunately I guess, by your reaction to my review, I was not able to express clearly in words. Maybe I'll edit it later to try and explain it better for those who don't quite get what I am refering too.
I have to agree with you for the most part of the initial run of the series and the end except that the bigger picture of the story was having two mini-stories in one huge story. They have two sets of main characters (in this case Shinn/Kira and Shinn/Athrun) and play each set in a different time. The first 15 were about Kira and Shinn and how they were going to fight. Of course Kira made his decision fairly quickly, but it took Shinn a lot more than a small nudge to make his decision on how and who he was going to fight. The second half, the next 15 episodes, were Athrun and Shinn. We get more into why Athrun chose what he did and continuing on with who Shinn was fighting for. The last 21 episodes was a merging of both stories into one for a grand finale ending to the series. Unfortunately in the end, the writers of GSD didn't do a very good job of this. They weren't able to correctly give spotlight to each main character as equally as they should.
All in all I enjoyed your detailed review and I agree with most of it. Good work, keep writing.
I have to agree with you in most areas except for two parts. The first part was Dark's japanese voice. I actually prefer that over the english voice. It fits Dark's character more considering he is suppose to be several years older than Daisuke as far as how they look. He was supposed to be portrayed as a 17 to 18 year old male not a 14 year old that is why his voice was deeper which suited him best. The second part was your rating for the story. Yes we all have our opinions on animes. I just felt your rating was a tad lower than the story should've gotten. Overall great review but lay back on the abbreviations like 'OMG'. It just doesn't work will in a review ^_^
Well I appreciate what you guys said, but my review was not biased. I did this review from the most neutral stand point. I, as a viewer, just couldn't find many things wrong with this series. I'm sorry if my unbiased opinion doesn't meet up to other people's review of this series. I tried to think of things wrong with this series but in the end, I couldn't think of anything major. The minor things I found that were wrong with it I clearly stated in my review. *hint hint* why this review didn't give the show a 10. If I was truly biased I would've gone that route.
I just want to say in response: "Well excuse me for having such a small vocabulary. Sorry I am not as perfect as you are and I'm sorry that my OPINION (which frankly that is what a review is) doesn't match up to your standards."
You know what, I have to give props, because this is the first review I have read that I agree with 100%. Every rating you gave are the ratings I would give. Maybe for slightly different reasons but they are about the same. Great review, I enjoyed reading it.
"Gravity" song RULES!
I agree with you mostly about this anime. Its very well done and its got the tone that makes you want to watch it again. Though I can't agree with you when it comes to both art and presentation. I thought the art was excellent and I believe (despite having low budget) they made a right choice in making the art what it is. It set the tone for the anime. Presentation I believe was also well done, yes some points it gets boring in the serious if you don't quite understand what is going on but it is very interesting to watch every scene even if none of the episodes connect til the end. But that is just my opinion. Overall great review and I appreciate the scroe you gave this series on the music and story cause it deserves those 10s.
Another good interview, but I didn't care for this anime too much. It got extremely confusing at points in which it should've been clear. I do agree with the music though if that is some consolation.
I agree with this review though my scoring would've been a little bit higher. ^_^ but that is me
I agree somewhat but then again its your opinion ^_^